|
IS THE SOLAR SYSTEM CHAOTIC?
Introduction to Chaos and Fractals |
By the end of the Renaissance, scientists thought that the universe
was like a clock, and could be understood in terms of a small
number of physical laws.
In principle, the motions of
the planets could be predicted infinitely far into the future
-- the only restriction was
our ability to do the computations. The philosophy of "determinism"
was the basis of all of physical science -- any event or observation
could be predicted from preceeding events, provided the physical
laws were known.
The solar system was thought to be so clocklike that the Earl of Orrery (Charles Boyle, 1676-1731) built elaborate mechanical models of the solar system which were used to predict the positions of the planets. We now call such models "Orreries". Here is a picture of one.
Modern-day "Orreries" are computer programs that predict
the positions of the planets.
Click
here for a nice web based orrery for the solar system.
The determinalistic view of science changed in 1960 when a meteorologist named Edward Lorenz pointed out that for some physical systems, it is impossible to predict the future, even if we know all the relevant physical laws. This is because sometimes the calculation of what will happen depends on minute details of the present configuration of the system -- what mathemations call the "initial conditions". An example is the weather -- we are all familiar with the fact that it is possible to predict what the weather will be like for the next few days in a general way, but after that, weather forecasts tend to be fairly useless.
The famous statement Lorenz made was that if "a butterfly
flaps its wings" in China the initial conditions of the weather are
sufficiently changed that the long-term weather in New York would be
affected. Lorenz called systems like the weather "CHAOTIC" physical systems.
You would need to know the initial conditions infinitely accurately in
order to predict the weather, which is impossible.
Since Lorenz, many examples of CHAOS in nature have been suggested, from the solar system to the stock market.
In 1987, astronomers at MIT used a computer program
called the 'Digital Orrery' to calculate the orbit of Pluto for
the next 40 million years at 40 day
intervals. This is enough time for Pluto to complete 15,000 orbits of the
Sun. They found that
the orbit of Pluto is chaotic, that is, its long-term
shape depends very sensitively on the exact input parameters used to start
the calculations. Not knowing where Pluto is today to a
precision of less than one
kilometer adds up over thousands of orbits to make the predictions
vary over a wide range of possibilities.
More recently,
astronomers using a similar computer program
found that the orbits of Mercury, Venus, Earth and Mars may not be stable
over the timescale of a few billion years.
Depending on the exact initial conditions, the cumulative influences of
Jupiter and Saturn eventually cause the inner planets to have more elliptical orbits, and in some simulations, Earth, Mars or Venus are actually
ejected from the solar system.
This result is controversial, but even if such drastic things don't happen,
it still is impossible to specify the positions of the planets today
infinitely accurately -- and so the exact positions of the planets
several billion years now cannot be calculated.
FRACTALS are closely related to chaotic systems. A fractal is a geometrical
shape which looks the same when you magnify it an arbitrary number of times.
The interesting thing is that many fractals are very similar in appearance
to patterns in nature -- like ferns, branching trees, coastlines, even
cauliflower.
Some famous fractals are the Mandelbrot set and the Julia set. The Mandelbrot
set is shown at the top of this page. On the web there are sites that
allow you to "explore" the Mandelbrot fractal,
by putting your cursor on any part
of the image and zooming in.
Althernatively, you can have a look at some
animated gifs by Strumia and Alden,
here or here .
A very beautiful page with a nice non-mathematical description of
fractals is Fractal Journeys.
Here is one of their images
Fractals can be generated by specifying simple rules and repeating
them many times. Examples of how this works are the
Sierpinski Triangle,
the Jurasic
Park fractal, and the
Koch snowflake . Click on these sites and then click on the black
arrow pointing right to generate the fractal.
There are freeware programs on the web which you can use to generate your
own fractals. Classes can also generate fractals on Don Archer's
web site and they will be posted as art. He requests that you give him
some advanced warning if you have an entire class submit requests.
Don Archer's Fractal
art web site. Click on "U-draw Form" to make a
fractal image. He will send you email and post your art on the web.
The Fractory
web site. Click on "Make Your Own Fractals" and make a Mandelbrot
or Julia
fractal image.
For more information on Fractals, including lesson plans for K-12, see The Fractal Microscope .